Breakout Guardian v1.1.2 – Backtesting Results Completely Different From Website Stats

Started by Abdullah Alkaluf on Nov 21, 2025 at 7:23 AM
712 views 2 replies
Posted Nov 21, 2025 at 7:23 AM

Hi everyone,

I just updated to Breakout Guardian v1.1.2 and noticed something concerning.
The backtesting performance I’m getting locally is completely different from the performance shown on the strategy’s official Strategy Performance Analysis page.


1. My Backtesting Results (v1.1.2)

Using the same chart setup, same dates, same instrument (MES 12-25), same settings as before.
But now the results are drastically worse.

Screenshot:

Key numbers from my backtest:

  • Total Net Profit: –$735

  • Profit Factor: 0.97

  • Percent Profitable: 45.88%

  • 425 trades


2. Website Strategy Performance Analysis

On the strategy’s official performance page, the published stats are:

  • Total Net Profit: ~$17,000

  • Profit Factor: ~2.10

  • Percent Profitable: ~76%

These are dramatically different from what the new version (v1.1.2) produces in NinjaTrader using identical conditions.


3. Important Notes

  • Only the strategy version changed.

  • Same VPS, same data provider, same workspace, same instrument, same settings.

  • Previous versions never had this large performance difference.

  • Other strategies (Low Volume Hunter, Goldilocks) still match their historical performance normally.

Posted Nov 21, 2025 at 8:40 AM
Hi Abdullah

Same here. Wrote it here:
https://futures.aeromir.com/forums/breakout-guardian-general-discussion/32

Greez from Switzerland
Michael
Posted Nov 22, 2025 at 6:08 AM
Abdullah Alkaluf said:

Hi everyone,

I just updated to Breakout Guardian v1.1.2 and noticed something concerning.
The backtesting performance I’m getting locally is completely different from the performance shown on the strategy’s official Strategy Performance Analysis page.


1. My Backtesting Results (v1.1.2)

Using the same chart setup, same dates, same instrument (MES 12-25), same settings as before.
But now the results are drastically worse.

Screenshot:

Key numbers from my backtest:

  • Total Net Profit: –$735

  • Profit Factor: 0.97

  • Percent Profitable: 45.88%

  • 425 trades


2. Website Strategy Performance Analysis

On the strategy’s official performance page, the published stats are:

  • Total Net Profit: ~$17,000

  • Profit Factor: ~2.10

  • Percent Profitable: ~76%

These are dramatically different from what the new version (v1.1.2) produces in NinjaTrader using identical conditions.


3. Important Notes

  • Only the strategy version changed.

  • Same VPS, same data provider, same workspace, same instrument, same settings.

  • Previous versions never had this large performance difference.

  • Other strategies (Low Volume Hunter, Goldilocks) still match their historical performance normally.

same here too 

Want to join the discussion?

Login or create an account to reply to this thread.